Book 1 - The Portable Edgar Allan Poe
Posted by Holly on 19 Jan 2009 | Tagged as: Book Challenge 2009
Title: The Portable Edgar Allan Poe
Editor: J. Gerald Kennedy
Read between: 01/01/09 - 01/09/09
Thoughts: This book is not only a collection of stories and poems by Edgar Allan Poe, but also is a collection of some of his personal letters and excepts of his critical writing and observations. Through these additional writings, I came to know Poe as more than a writer of macabre stories.
Most of the short stories in this anthology I had never read before or at least did not remember reading them. My favorite stories still remained favorites though I did discover a few new ones as well. My favorite stories seem to be the strange ones with somewhat unexpected endings. By far my favorite story has always been ‘The Masque of the Red Death’ because of the atmosphere that I always imagine as regards to the color themed decorations of the rooms and because of the sudden appearance of the personification of the Red Death itself. Two other old favorites were ‘The Cask of Amontillado’ and ‘The Black Cat’, while I discovered a new one in ‘William Wilson’.
As for the poems, I was not much for them because a theme common to many of them was the mourning of the loss of a beautiful woman, a theme I do not go looking for in poetry. Also some of the poems felt terribly personal to the point that I felt that reading them out loud was uncomfortable for me. I attribute this to the fact that I know that Poe’s poetry was often a reaction to the own events in his personal life, especially the poem ‘For Annie’. My favorite poem, of course, was ‘The Raven’.
In reading the letters and other writings of Poe’s, I became more aware of him as a man of his time and how his life and temperament influenced his works. They reminded me that his writings were not written in a vacuum as one might feel when just reading one of his stories by itself. However, he was clearly connected to the literary world of early 19th century America and was a man with his own views on what others wrote. He also seemed to have had some sort of mood disorder from some of his own descriptions of himself. What kind of mood disorder, I don’t know, but he probably had one. He also seemed to be quite vocal in his opinions and criticism. He was a very interesting man.